Should India increase or decrease the amount of temporary work visas given to high-skilled immigrant workers?
Skilled temporary work visas are usually given to foreign scientists, engineers, programmers, architects, executives, and other positions or fields where demand outpaces supply. Most businesses argue that hiring skilled foreign workers allows them to competitively fill positions which are in high demand. Opponents argue that skilled immigrants decrease middle class wages and job tenure.
Narrow down the conversation to these participants:
Political theme:
We should bring a particular amount so that they can help upskill our people. We can really use experience of highly skilled professionals from other countries
@9K2JFLYIndependent10mos10MO
It may be kept as it is currently, but there may be more incentives or free access programs offered but the government to both prepare and invite local people for the said job.
@9FMZP8H1yr1Y
Decrease India has enough people to fit its jobs
@8W2JD2L3yrs3Y
Increase cause Highly Skilled people let the country to be World's Best Country to be live
Government should make its citizens highly skilled rather than bringing more immigrants
Increase, and ensure they get minimum wage. Also, the government must invest more in open skill development programs
@98JKVTXBharatiya Janata2yrs2Y
Work visas should be given only to hindu immigrants
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@92ZYZRW3yrs3Y
Increase, The whole point of the american dream is that everyone gets an opportunity.
@4SNPK4B3yrs3Y
Increase (in fact I favor abolishing this restriction on immigration)
@8QDSNZY4yrs4Y
Increase, but I'd rather just grant them citizenship
@vacheesehead3yrs3Y
Increase and decrease based in the current economic state
@88LK76J4yrs4Y
Increase only for legals
@8RMRZTM4yrs4Y
Increase, but also incentivize a path to citizenship, or pass automatic citizenship eligibility after a certain period of time. Also, be less aggressive towards immigrant workers who overstay their visa
@8WVSFDZ3yrs3Y
Neither, but screening visas would have prevented some of the 911 hijackers.
@6HDD83R4yrs4Y
End and avoid establishing or re-establishing diplomatic relations with Saudi Arabia, Yemen, United Arab Emirates, Qatar, Iran, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Maldives, Brunei, Palestine, Somalia, Mauritania, Comoros, the People's Republic of China, Vietnam, Laos, North Korea, Somaliland, Kosovo, Transnistria, South Ossetia, Artsakh, Abkhazia, Northern Cyprus and Venezuela
@92JXK3J2yrs2Y
I like the current amount, but reform the system so that companies cannot take advantage of the program to decrease wages.
@92YHQCV3yrs3Y
Decrease, companies are currently taking advantage of this program to decrease wages, even though Immigration helps to Make America Great
@3L4VJYP4yrs4Y
Decrease, companies are currently taking advantage of this program to decrease wages, and we should create our avenues for citizenship
@michaelconnely3yrs3Y
Economic cycles can be predicted based on population ages. To maintain a more uniform economy, a stable population across all ages should be implemented. Work visa numbers should be based on this factor and shortages needed in the labor force.
@4ZTD62K4yrs4Y
A work visa should not be needed for a migrant worker to be hired.
@6NLNK8C4yrs4Y
Increase in fields with a higher demand than citizens can fulfill. Decrease for fields in which immigrants stand to take Americans' jobs.
@6R6HBQ34yrs4Y
Regardless, the government should implement an open border policy
@7Q6YR423yrs3Y
Neither decrease nor increase, regardless of who does the job it should get done to a high standard regardless of price or nationality.
@7PTCG383yrs3Y
Increase at this current point in time, but the government should provide more incentives to prepare our citizens for these jobs
@7PTCG383yrs3Y
I am satisfied with the current amount, but make it easier for immigrants to obtain these temporary work visas
@7PTCG383yrs3Y
Increase, and the government should also provide more incentives to prepare our citizens for these jobs
@7PTCG383yrs3Y
I am satisfied with the current amount, but sponsor and increase skilled corporate training programs so domestic workers may successfully compete for these positions
@85QWNPG3yrs3Y
Increase, our population is set to decline in the coming decades and the only true way to stop this in a first world nation (of which we are barely), is to bring in high skilled foreign labor so that they may set up a family here and keep the economic flow moving. Currently countries such as Japan and Korea which sought to keep out much foreign influence on the economy are feeling the strain of putting that burden on an aging population.
@86N5Z353yrs3Y
Increase, but penalize companies who are currently taking advantage of this program to decrease wages
@7PTCG384yrs4Y
Decrease, we should prioritize offering these jobs to qualified domestic workers and utilize skilled immigrant workers only when demand exceeds our available supply.
@7PTCG384yrs4Y
Decrease, we should prioritize offering these jobs to qualified domestic workers and utilize skilled immigrant workers only when demand exceeds our available supply
@8G78S5G4yrs4Y
Increase, but we should greatly increase temporary student visas
@8GFFTDB4yrs4Y
Decrease, but highly skilled immigrants should be granted citizenship
@8GMPK8G4yrs4Y
They should increase but there should be laws the businesses have to follow so they get paid just as much as everyone else.
@8GTWWZJ4yrs4Y
Not informed enough for a full opinion.
@8H9VXZQ4yrs4Y
I believe company are taking advantage of this such as Disney as well as COVID 19 putting a lot of people out of work.
@8QM9QMR4yrs4Y
i do not have enough information to conduct a stance.
@8MMFD8C4yrs4Y
i believe work visas are not the problem of immigration. i believe temporary work visas should be given out, but immigrants should not overstay past the visas expiration date.
@abbymayart4yrs4Y
Increase, these highly skilled people should be allowed into the country because it helps the economy BUT they should be hired at the same salary as someone who is from here.
@8NY47RM4yrs4Y
Increase, but only to highly skilled individuals.
@8NY4BWF4yrs4Y
I would like to understand why anyone actually believes that we need people from other countries to come in to be highly skilled workers. There is not any path for these individuals to become residents under this Visa. Create visas that are temp for those that want an education, but if you are coming here, working here, having children here, then you should have a legitimate path to citizenship. The only Visas that have such a path at this point are costly and do not really work now.
@8PSV2S44yrs4Y
Increase and expand current programs to ensure these workers are protected and fairly compensated.
@8RM3NHC4yrs4Y
increase, but prevent companies from taking advantage of these programs to decrease wages
@8SG6GF54yrs4Y
Visas should be issued based on need.
@8VC7WDN3yrs3Y
Decrease, we need to focus on our workers first not that of foreign nationals
@8WP5BCC3yrs3Y
Personally I feel like if you feel like you need a "foreigner" to help you figure something out that's cool but I feel like it should be 50/50.
@8ZPHR883yrs3Y
Increase, but insure that their labor rights are not being infringed upon, and they're not being taken advantage of.
@8WQT4F93yrs3Y
I need more construction workers.
@Thomasj663yrs3Y
No, make sure citizens are qualified while also letting in people.
@8XNT9ZQ3yrs3Y
It needs to be the right amount of visas per job. I have worked in hospitals that import nurses and refuse to high new graduates from local colleges/universities. They say the imported nurses have experience - that's a joke! I had to spend months with my colleagues training them.
@923Z93G3yrs3Y
Decrease, and abolish all work visa programs
@93X4TMH2yrs2Y
Increase, but only after we adequately equip our citizens with the necessary resources for these jobs
@93RQL4H2yrs2Y
It should remain status quo, but we should be penalizing companies that look for loopholes and try to hire immigrants for cheaper work by making sure the minimum wage is increased.
@8WNLM9C3yrs3Y
Keep it at the same rate but have the government make sure that these workers are being paid the same as U.S Citizens would and that they are being treated fairly. Have them treated as they have all the same basic rights we have under U.S.A’s government.
@9334YP33yrs3Y
The US should only issue any kind of visas to high-skilled heterosexual cisgender Christian immigrants.
@MSelvig3yrs3Y
Keep it the same for now, while remembering that we should be encouraging our own citizens to work toward these jobs.
Deleted4yrs4Y
Decrease, push for intelligent high-skilled immigrants working within the US to become legalized citizens.
@8Z6PZKW3yrs3Y
Decrease, and you should have to live in the US to have a job in the US
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
@ISIDEWITH1yr1Y
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...
Join in on more popular conversations.