Should Muslim immigrants be banned from entering the country until the government improves its ability to screen out potential terrorists?
Proponents argue that this strategy would bolster national security by minimizing the risk of potential terrorists entering the country. Enhanced screening processes, once implemented, would provide a more thorough assessment of applicants, reducing the likelihood of malicious actors gaining entry. Critics argue that such a policy might inadvertently promote discrimination by broadly categorizing individuals based on their nation of origin rather than specific, credible threat intelligence. It may strain diplomatic relations with the affected countries and potentially harm the perception of the nation enacting the ban, being seen as hostile or prejudiced towards certain international communities. Additionally, genuine refugees fleeing terrorism or persecution in their home countries might be unjustly denied safe haven.
@8F2BB6S4yrs4Y
Background checks should be done thoroughly on any immigrant entering the country
No, but terrorism screening should be conducted for all immigrants, regardless of religion.
@92QJ8LZBharatiya Janata2yrs2Y
yes , untill they leave their muslim religion and converts to other religion in india
@925D62Z2yrs2Y
While banning people on religious basis is wrong, government should be more thorough with background check and should create specialized test to screen out potential radical elements while allowing hard working immigrants
@8Z7Y6H8Independent2yrs2Y
Only skilled immigrants with deep pockets and better screening
@8YSBBW4Bharatiya Janata2yrs2Y
Immigration laws need to be stricter, immigration should not be banned
@9CT2LTXBharatiya Janata9mos9MO
Muslim migrants should be blanket banned from entering India forever. There are 10s of islamic nations surrounding India. They can take these migrants.
Ban all immigration irrespective of religion
@9CS69WBBharatiya Janata9mos9MO
No immigrant shot be allowed
Absolutely not This might lead to more segregation and alienation
Should be applicable to everyone immigrating, regardless of religion.
@9CQW4249mos9MO
India should not allow Muslim Immigrants at all
Deleted9mos9MO
Illegal immigrants need to be banned, screening capacity needs to be better
@9CQHM6R9mos9MO
Background check should be done. If there is a red flag ban them from entering. Not all
@9CQHGHWIndependent9mos9MO
No, but make the screening process more robust
@9CQFV6SBharatiya Janata9mos9MO
No muslim from any country should be allowed to immigrate in india
@9CQDNXFBharatiya Janata9mos9MO
Whether screening is improved or not, Muslim immigrants shouldn’t be allowed anyway into the country.
Ban any Muslim immigration regardless of whether or not they represent a terrorist threat.
@9CQBZ929mos9MO
No needs of unworthy immigrants in heavily populated countries like India
@9CQBG68Bharatiya Janata9mos9MO
Not at any circumstances. Complete ban.
@9CQB3CQIndependent9mos9MO
No, instead we should focus on improving our screening process but illegal Muslim immigrants need to be sent back
We already have enough population and diversity, no need to allow immigrants in !
@9CQ8RBF9mos9MO
Muslim immigrants should be banned permanently
@9CQ7TVHBharatiya Janata9mos9MO
No, but there must be extra precautions and screening process especially from high risk nations like Pakistan, Afghanistan, Yemen, Syria etc
@9CQ6VMT9mos9MO
Ban regardless of religion, until the screening process is improved. After that, just follow normal regulations
@9CQ4VQSIndependent9mos9MO
No, It should be examined on a case by case basis
@9CQ4QXV9mos9MO
Already the MHA looks into each citizenship application, that should be enough.
Proper scrutiny should be done and 2 yrs of survillence.
@9CQ3647Independent9mos9MO
Muslims should be banned from every country
@9CQ2N8QBharatiya Janata9mos9MO
Ban them at all cost, ban them all
we have way too many of our own problems, we do not need to borrow other's problems, let the west and middle east, who keep lecturing about human rights of muslim migrants, take them as refugees. Muslims are better off there since we are 'tourting' the muslims here.
Terrorism has nothing to do with Muslims or Islam.
@9CPZSGYBharatiya Janata9mos9MO
No Muslims should be allowed regardless terrorists or not.
@9CPZLYLBharatiya Janata9mos9MO
All immigrants should be thoroughly screened and a proper background check should be done.Now banning Muslims specially is not acceptable but keeping in mind the historical context of partition and history of terrorism that has impacted this country individuals from high risk countries and backgrounds must be dealt with extra diligence and in some cases banned.
Government should improve screening without banning anyone.
@9CPYY3TBharatiya Janata9mos9MO
Muslim immigrants should be banned forever. And those who are already in, should be thrown out.
No. But government should improve its ability to screen out potential terrorists regardless of religion or irreligion.
@9CPY6SR9mos9MO
Muslims immigrants must be banned from entering the country irrespective of terrorists.
@9CPX84CIndependent9mos9MO
Immigrant of all religions should only be accepted after a proper screening by government
@9CPX4MMBharatiya Janata9mos9MO
Muslim immigrants must be ban
@9CPWWB4Bharatiya Janata9mos9MO
Ban muslim immigrants only from enemy countries like Pakistan until the screening process is improved.
@9CPWVL6Independent9mos9MO
Muslim immigrants should be banned to enter in country completely
@9CPWGYSIndependent9mos9MO
Yes, and never allow them
Avoid cultural fundamentalist Muslims because of cultural integrity
@938ZLH3Bharatiya Janata2yrs2Y
Yes, but decrease immigration from all countries and focus on providing for the current population of India
@8YCC7HZIndependent2yrs2Y
Immigration policies should be based on a country's ability to support it's citizens rather than religion.
@8Y4WLCY2yrs2Y
Government should focus on improving its intelligence to better detect potential terrorists and religion should not be a criteria for allowing or disallowing immigrants in the country.
@8Y437RS2yrs2Y
No, there should be robust background check. No religion should be banned.
@8XXCPCZBharatiya Janata2yrs2Y
No, but can be allowed in emergencies and if the person doesn't believe in intolerant memes
The historical activity of users engaging with this question.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...