Trade unions in India have experienced tremendous growth in the past five years. The Indian National Trade Union Congress (INTUC), affiliated to the Congress party, has emerged as the biggest of the seven central trade unions, with a membership of 33.3 million.
@9LP7SQ4 3 days3D
It is the role of country to look after its people and labour union help in securing worker rights and fair wage but at the same the it should be fair and shouldn’t hurt the economy a lot
@9HRZR58Bharatiya Janata4mos4MO
It depends on certain unions. Suspicious unions which involve in unfair activites and are hurting the economy should be investigated and banned from forming again.
@9FQ56TP7mos7MO
depends on the need to strike
@9D33F3D9mos9MO
Help if it is well organized and functions in the way it should, free of corruption and unnecessary bias.
Hurt the economy in the short run, but necessary for a healthy economy.
@92QJ8LZBharatiya Janata2yrs2Y
help , but they must be registered with labour ministry so as to check that they do not stall the work unnecesarily
@8YWPRRXIndependent2yrs2Y
well some damage the economy in a bad way which i don't like and some help the economy to grow. For example if they demand higher pay that's they'll have more money to spend which will boost the economy and some often hold protests which causes serious damages which is not good
@8V5KKZ6Independent3yrs3Y
Hurt , but in a democracy it is quintessential
@8TSBN8LBharatiya Janata3yrs3Y
Help if they are not communist.
@8TFHNSRIndependent3yrs3Y
Hurt, even then should not go away with them.
@8TBL8DVBharatiya Janata3yrs3Y
Ok moderation they help take care of employees but shouldn’t go to the extent of overthrowing the organisation
Help but should not be politicised
@8T5WLT8Biju Janata Dal3yrs3Y
How much helps, that much hurts
@8S3C6JW3yrs3Y
they are helpful for the economy, labour unions are important, but they should follow the Gandhian approach, instead of marxist approach.
@8RYCMZQBharatiya Janata3yrs3Y
Depends, they sometimes act as feudal and corrupt institutions.
@8RWH9323yrs3Y
There's no one answer. Labour unions are needed against exploitation sometimes
@8PZNSDJBharatiya Janata3yrs3Y
Some Labor unions helps, some hurts.
@9CQYQS8Marxist Communist9mos9MO
Help, it is the only way to democratise in the current situation.
@9CQN5B4Independent10mos10MO
They're fighting for workers' rights but in the foundation of capitalism. Not prepared to transition to another system.
@9CQKMPSIndian National Congress10mos10MO
It's depends case to case. To be honest there are unions who have done well on the other hand there are corrupted ones too.
@9CQG7F710mos10MO
If a private union adds more layers before an output or decision is reached then they hurt the economy. But the question is if people welfare is affected and if that will impact economy in the long run.
@9CQFJSZ10mos10MO
Labourer's life matter more than economy.
@9CQDTK210mos10MO
Unions are good but they're not necessarily innocent all the time. All their funding must be audited every year.
@9CQDNXFBharatiya Janata10mos10MO
They should have limited powers to prevent exploitation
@9CQB8PJ10mos10MO
They Hurt, and that is a good thing
@9CQ6NHDBahujan Samaj10mos10MO
Labour unions are necessary for healthy economy, at the same time their ambitions to increase their wage or income sometimes hurt economic, when wages increase, price also increase, which creates cost bulid up inflation
@9CQ5D8ZIndian National Congress10mos10MO
Typically help but they are sometimes a barrier to industrialisation so it's about picking the lesser of two evils at our stage of development
@9CQ4QXV10mos10MO
Politicians heading unions must be banned, only workmen should have representation and politicians should not have any direct role in any union.
@9CQ2YTF10mos10MO
@9CQ25GTNationalist Congress10mos10MO
In certain situations, they help, in others they are problematic
@9CPZZSLIndependent10mos10MO
They often hurt economic growth but also provide substantial protection to workers, providing some economic benefits long term.
@9CPYCW7Indian National Congress10mos10MO
Help, but power imbalances and union laws should be aggressively discussed & scrutinized in light of recent misuses
They sometimes hurt and sometimes help
Help, but they should have a independent and neutral oversight
@95Z94THIndependent2yrs2Y
Hurt, but are essential to safeguard workers'rights.
@95WHXRLIndependent2yrs2Y
Help but workers active participation required and less interference by employers
Help , but criminal activities done by Trade union members must be investigated and when found guilty, must be given the suitable punishment.
@8XXCPCZBharatiya Janata2yrs2Y
Help, but only to some degree
@8XLWCGB2yrs2Y
I don't have any knowledge about it
Hurt if political interests involve
@8VJTWMLIndependent3yrs3Y
We need unions to hear their grievances if they propose true problems and causes we need to take their views into account
@8QQP994Bharatiya Janata3yrs3Y
Labor Unions have a social aim rather than an economic one, so the question is incorrect.
Can help or hurt based on objectives of the union
@8Q2PNDYIndependent3yrs3Y
In an open society, freedom of association is an important plank. Collective bargaining in itself is not evil. Issues between businesses and unions need not be confrontational.
@8Q2M9623yrs3Y
Workers have a right to unionize, regardless of its effect on economy.
@8PLX4T93yrs3Y
Sometimes yes sometimes no based on the situation
@8P25ZW7Bharatiya Janata3yrs3Y
They protect the interests of workers, but they interfere in the development of the country due to frequent strikes.
@3FVY82W2yrs2Y
Not much impact on the overall economy one way or the other
The historical activity of users engaging with this question.
Loading data...
Loading chart...
Loading the political themes of users that engaged with this discussion
Loading data...